The college admissions process in the United States has become increasingly complex over the past two decades, while the ways that colleges choose who to admit have become more and more opaque. There’s so much information (and misinformation) out there about applying for college and how to make yourself a competitive applicant —taking honors and AP classes, joining extracurricular activities at school, doing community service, getting a good SAT or ACT score, getting internships and filling your summers—you may not realize how much time and energy the actual college application process takes until it’s too late.
In truth, the best thing you can do for yourself when thinking about college is to plan ahead. With time, you can manage the college admissions process, keep your stress under control, ensure you’re putting together the best possible application materials, and maximize your chances of admission to your top-choice schools. Without time, no matter how many accomplishments you had in high school, you’ll be flailing, stressed, and compromising on your college applications.
To that end, understanding how to apply for college is as important as understanding what colleges look for in applicants. Here’s a step-by-step guide with tips for applying to college to ensure you’re in the driver’s seat.
The first thing you’ll want to do is break out the college application process into stages and consider when you’re going to accomplish each piece.
Initially, creating this list will likely make the process seem daunting; as you think about it, you’ll probably begin to add more and more tasks. While this will be scary at first, it’s actually healthy because it will reinforce what a big project applying for college is and how seriously you need to take it. We’ve put together a basic list below, but you’ll also want to think about your unique situation.
Once you’ve done that, you’ll want to think about when you’re going to accomplish all these tasks! Consider making a monthly or even weekly schedule with everything you know you have on the calendar already, and start filling in your college tasks. Remember, you may want all this done by the Early Decision deadline of November 1, so plan accordingly!
Some tasks will be big, like when you have time to visit schools or schedule interviews. Most of the rest, though, will be small. Can you set aside time each week to research a different school or major? When will you work on your essays? For these aspects of the application process for college, doing a little bit at a time will be much more effective than taking it all on at once.
The first step in applying to college is figuring out which colleges to apply to! Maybe you have a list of dream schools, or maybe you’re starting from scratch choosing a college list. Either way, you’re going to want to set out a significant amount of time during your junior year of high school to research colleges. Ask yourself: do you want to be in a city or a more secluded place? A big school or a small school? An engineering/tech school or a liberal arts program? Public or private?
As you find schools you like, consider what they have in common, and use those core factors to figure out what you want in a college. That way, you can begin to narrow down your list.
Once you’ve done your research, you can make a list of colleges to which you plan on applying. It’s OK if the list is long at this point; usually 20-25 schools is good for an initial list. As you start to visit and research more in depth, you’ll find that some aren’t a good fit for you. Over time, you should plan to narrow your list down to somewhere around 10 schools with a range of competitiveness amongst the schools on your list.
Even at this early stage, try to list schools that vary in selectivity. Don’t go for only schools with single-digit admission rates; you’ll need some schools where you’re more likely to get in. This is one part of the process of choosing a college in which outside advice can be immensely helpful!
The fewer surprises along the way, the better. Start tracking down application deadlines, deadlines to sign up for interviews, dates for information sessions, and any other pertinent information about the schools on your list. Once you’ve done that, it’ll be much clearer what the things you need to do now are, and what can be left until later. Don’t forget about those later things, though! Make sure they’re in your application calendar too, so when the time comes, you’ll remember to do them.
Click here to see our high school senior checklist that is aimed at helping you keep on track of every step of the college application process as you navigate your final year of high school!
Even though your teachers and guidance counselor won’t be submitting these letters to colleges until the fall of senior year, it’s still very important to ask for recommendation letters at the end of junior year, as they will be from your junior year teachers. High school teachers and school counselors get a lot of letter requests and may cap the number they’re willing to write. They also may want you to fill out a questionnaire to help them write you the strongest possible letter.
Similarly, you may ask a coach, mentor, employer, or advisor for recommendation letters to colleges as well, and it’s always good practice to ask well in advance. These are considered “additional recommenders” and are submitted through the Common Application. These recommendations would be in addition to the teacher and guidance counselor recommendations. Recommenders, whatever their relationship to you, are doing you a favor, so ask politely and say thank you if they agree!
Another part of the process you’ll want to plan ahead for is when you’re going to take (or retake, or retake again!) the SAT or ACT. If you know you’re the kind of person who needs very good test scores for your dream school, start planning ahead!
It’s also important to keep in mind that the SAT and ACT only offer certain test dates, and some are immensely popular. So, sign up for your preferred date early, and start studying now! Of course, there are now many schools that are test-optional, so you can consider whether devoting time to standardized testing makes sense for you.
While not all colleges and universities offer on-campus or alumni interviews, signing up at those that do is a great way to learn more about the school and sincerely demonstrate your interest. Once you know which of the schools on your initial list of colleges offer interviews, look into signing up. Then, once you have a date, start preparing to make a good impression. These college interviews can definitely make a difference in your chances of admission.
When it comes to on-campus versus Zoom interviews, admissions officers give them equal weight in the process. Also, many interviews are with current students or alumni. Those interviews are just as good as interviews with admissions officers too. That said, if a college offers on-campus interviews and you can get there, you should definitely take advantage of that possibility.
By the middle of the summer before senior year, you should know enough about the colleges on your list and your chances of admission to narrow down your list into its final form. There’s no hard maximum or minimum (although the Common Application will only allow you to apply to 20 schools), but you want to have a good mix of selectivity.
While it might feel too early in the process of choosing a college to settle on your schools, it’s important to finalize this list over the summer so you don’t drown in application essays. If you are applying to top schools, you could have as many as 30 or 40 essays!
There are two kinds of college essays: your Common App essay (or personal statement essay), which will go to all of your schools, and shorter, school-specific essays. The essay prompts for the personal essay for the Common App generally become available well in advance, but the college-specific essay prompts for each school’s essays usually aren’t finalized until the first week in August.
Nevertheless, you don’t want to be wasting precious time during the fall of your senior year writing application essays when you could be studying or participating in extracurricular activities. Thus, it’s crucial to get as much writing done over the summer as possible.
In addition to the application process for admission, if you’re planning to apply for financial aid to support your higher education, you’ll need to keep track of that process too. During the fall of your senior year, make sure you’re filling out the forms for FAFSA, the federal financial aid and student loan program, as well as keeping an eye out for scholarships and merit aid.
Again, while the deadline for financial aid applications is either concurrent with or later than the admissions deadline, it’s imperative that you stay on top of the process.
This last step is optional, but it is important for many students. It is well documented that at a significant number of schools, students who apply in the early decision round benefit from a higher admission rate than students who apply regular decision. If your top-choice school is one such school, it is worth strongly considering applying early decision. In addition, many schools have two early decision rounds, which means you could have a first-round (EDI) school choice and a second-round (EDII) school choice where you can apply if you do not get into your EDI school.
Some students find it hard to make such a big decision in November; they want to have options to pick from in the spring. That’s understandable, but, as counterintuitive as it sounds, you may be limiting your options by not applying early, given the higher admission rates at so many schools. A school that would take you early might not take you in regular decision.
In the fall of your senior year, it’ll be time to put together the actual application. Almost all US colleges and universities use the Common Application, but some use the competing Coalition Application. If you can’t find the school through the Common App search function, check its admissions website.
Regardless of the interface, you’ll be asked for the following information:
This is exactly what it sounds like: your name, your date of birth, your educational history, etc. You’ll also be asked for information about your parents and their educational histories, so make sure to check in with them. This is also the place where you’ll fill in details about your extracurricular activities as well as any awards and honors you’ve received.
Because the personal statement essay goes to all your schools, you upload it in the main part of the Common Application (or Coalition Application), rather than the individual school sections. Be sure to write this in a separate word processing software document, so you can check for spelling and grammar errors or show it to an advisor for feedback. Then, copy and paste the text into your online application.
Once you’ve filled in all the information in the main application, you’ll need to answer a few more questions and potentially add essays for each school on your list. Be careful to answer all the questions; otherwise, your application may not submit! Again, plan to write and revise your supplemental essays separately, then copy and paste them into the online application.
You will also need to send your high school transcript to all the schools to which you’re applying. Because these almost always need to be official transcripts, they should come directly from your guidance counselor or school official. Your school likely uses a program like Naviance or Scoir to manage this. If you’re unsure, talk to your guidance counselor.
Just like your transcripts, your recommendation letters to colleges need to come directly from your teachers or other recommenders. Your teachers will use the school’s system, but you’ll have to add any outside letter writers directly to each college’s portion of the application. If that isn’t an option for the school, teachers can mail the letters directly to the admissions office.
Most schools also want you to send official score reports from the SAT or ACT, though many colleges are now test-optional. Many colleges now accept self-reported SAT, ACT and AP scores in the application. However, not every school allows this, so please check the requirements on each college’s website. If self-reporting is not permitted, you will need to send the college your SAT or ACT scores from the College Board or ACT site.
Lastly, once everything in your application is completely done, you’ll need to pay an application fee to each school. These college application cost ranges from around $50 to $100, depending on the school. This fee is important for two reasons. One, it’s a cost to consider when applying. And two, it means you must submit each school’s application separately. Even if they’re all grouped under the Common App, there’s no one button to submit them all!
Colleges understand that these college application costs can be a significant burden to students and families. For that reason, most American universities offer students the option to apply for a waiver that releases them from the application fee. These application fee waivers are given to students who can show that the fees present a significant financial burden.
You can apply for a waiver in one of four ways: through the College Board (if you took the SAT or SAT Subject Tests), through the Common App itself, through the National Association for College Admissions Counseling (NACAC), or through individual college admissions offices.
Each requires proof of financial hardship (often through evidence of qualifying for low-income housing, free or reduced lunch, or other forms of public assistance), as well as confirmation from your guidance counselor. The application is not as straightforward as it might be, but it’s important to know that these college application costs should not keep you from applying.
No matter how much wonderful stuff you’re bringing to the college admissions process, your strengths and uniqueness are likely to get lost in the shuffle if you don’t manage the process effectively. Develop a strategy, make a plan, and stay focused when applying for college! If you stay ahead of the game, you’ll be in a much better position to submit strong, successful college applications. If you have time to plan ahead and would like to learn more about using a college admissions consultant, please schedule a free consultation.
Contact us to learn more about our admissions consulting services.