Common App Sections That Matter for College Success

The Common Application can feel overwhelming the first time you log into your Common App account. With dozens of required fields, optional questions, and the infamous Common App essay prompts, it’s easy to worry that you’ll miss something critical. The truth? Not every section of the Common App carries the same weight with an admissions officer or admissions committee.

This guide will show you what really matters and what’s just noise. You’ll learn how to make your activities section shine, how to prepare strong letters of recommendation, when to use the additional information section, and how to approach your supplemental essays strategically. We’ll also cover the most common mistakes students make when filling out each section of the Common App and how to avoid them.

What Actually Matters on the Common Application

Admissions officers review applications holistically, but not every part of the Common App has equal weight. Think of your application in tiers:

What Matters Most	What Helps	What’s Mostly Noise
Personal statement / Common App essay	Academic honors	Middle school activities
Activities list (with clear order of importance)	Testing section context	Similar activities repeated
Supplemental essays	Leadership roles in community service	Excessive formatting
Letters of recommendation	Grades section consistency	Optional sections filled with fluff
Academic record	Education section details	Long additional info with no value

Your Common App essay, supplemental essays, activities section, and letters of recommendation collectively tell the story of who you are beyond test scores. Meanwhile, things like a gimmick in your writing or extra “optional” uploads rarely move the needle.

The Personal Statement vs. Supplements

Anything you can write in your own words that displays your core values and future goals will be of value to the admissions committee. They want to know how you will contribute to the university, not only academically, but holistically.

The Common App Essay Prompts

The personal essay, better known as the Common App essay, remains the heart of the application. The prompts can change slightly from year to year, but all are designed to reveal your voice, growth, and values. Don’t overthink the choice; pick the essay prompt that allows you to tell a genuine story in your own words.

An essay that answers the question and shows reflection will always outweigh one that tries to impress with big words but reveals little about you. For instance:

• Before: “I joined National Honor Society and Future Business Leaders of America to add activities to my résumé.”
• After: “When I became treasurer of Future Business Leaders of America, I realized numbers could tell a story. Balancing fundraising spreadsheets taught me how small choices shape community outcomes.”

The personal statement isn’t about perfection; it’s about growth and impact.

The Importance of Supplemental Essays

Too many students treat supplemental essays as afterthoughts. But admissions officers often use them to decide between equally qualified applicants. These short essays show how you’ll fit into a specific school’s community.

For example, a “Why Us?” essay should avoid repeating website facts. Instead, connect your interests to opportunities at that university. This is where demonstrating knowledge of programs, professors, or community service initiatives can set you apart.

Order Matters in the Activities Section

Even just a quick list of your extracurriculars and hobbies will give the admissions committee a glimpse into who you are and what you prioritize.

Choosing the Right Order

The Common App activities section is deceptively tricky. You only have 10 slots and 150 characters per description. Admissions officers care most about your top five activities, so the order of importance is crucial. Always lead with the most significant roles by time commitment, leadership, or impact.

• Before (weak ordering): Babysitting, soccer captain, science research internship, National Honor Society, community service club.
• After (strong ordering): Science research internship, soccer captain, community service club, babysitting, National Honor Society.

Writing Strong Descriptions

Avoid vague phrases like “helped with” or “participated in.” Instead, use strong verbs that show leadership and growth.

• Before: “Worked on school newspaper.”
• After: “Led 11th-grade editorial team; published 12 feature articles, doubling readership.”

Quantify impact when possible: hours per school year, results achieved, or skills learned. Remember, the activities list is an opportunity to showcase your involvement in various extracurricular activities, not just list clubs you’re a part of.

Who to Choose for Letters of Recommendation

Once you’ve identified the people in your life who have helped you the most with your leadership, academic, or career path, you will have a good idea of who should write your letters of recommendation.

Choosing the Right Recommenders

Strong letters of recommendation provide insight into your character and contributions that grades alone can’t show. Choose teachers who know you well beyond the classroom, can speak to growth across multiple school years, and have seen you lead or persist through challenges.

Most colleges require two academic recommendations and one from a school counselor. More is not always better; an extra letter of recommendation only helps if it adds a new perspective, such as the coach of your club soccer team or your research advisor at the local university.

Related Article: How Many Teacher Recommendations Do You Need for College?

Prepping Your Recommenders

Provide your recommenders with a “brag sheet” that includes your top extracurricular activities, academic honors, and goals. Meet with them early, ideally by the end of 11th grade, so they have plenty of time. The better prepared they are, the stronger their letters will be.

Honors and Awards Section

The Honors and Awards section is an often-underestimated part of the Common App that can provide significant insight into your academic trajectory and commitment to excellence. This section allows you to showcase any accolades, scholarships, or recognitions you’ve received throughout your high school career. When filling out this section, think about the weight and context of each honor. Prioritize recognitions that directly relate to your intended field of study or demonstrate leadership and perseverance.

Be specific: instead of simply listing awards, include a brief descriptor if the award is less well-known, explaining its significance and your role in achieving it. For example, rather than stating “Honor Roll,” clarify, “Achieved Honor Roll status for three consecutive years, recognizing academic excellence across subjects.” The key is clarity and relevance, ensuring that these accolades are adequately reflected in the narrative of your academic journey.

Optional Portfolio Submission with College Application

The optional portfolio submission can significantly enhance your college application by showcasing your creative skills and unique talents. While not all colleges require a portfolio, those that do provide students a chance to present their work and highlight personal achievements beyond what’s captured in the Common App.

This submission can include a variety of media, such as artwork, videos, writing samples, or any project that exemplifies your abilities and interests. Remember that quality trumps quantity; select only your best pieces that align with the program you are applying to. Additionally, accompany your portfolio with a brief narrative that explains the context of each piece, your creative process, and the skills demonstrated. This narrative can offer a glimpse into your passion and dedication, making your application more memorable.

Always follow the specific guidelines provided by the school to ensure that your submission meets their expectations, and consider showing your portfolio to mentors for feedback before sending it off.

When Should You Use the Additional Information Section?

The additional information section is optional, but it can be powerful when used correctly. Appropriate uses include:

• Explaining disruptions (such as illness, family responsibilities, or school changes).
• Clarifying unusual time commitments (like working 20 hours per week).
• Adding context for academic honors or unique projects.

What to skip? Don’t paste extra essays, repeat your extracurricular activities, or fill space with fluff. Admissions officers appreciate brevity.

• Before (not useful): “I love photography, and I wanted to share more about it even though I already listed it in activities.”
• After (useful): “During 12th grade, my family relocated, which required a three-hour daily commute. This impacted the number of after-school activities I could attend.”

Think of the additional info section as a way to clarify, not to impress.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls

Knowing what admissions committees don’t want to see is just as important as knowing what they’re looking for in the application.

Tone and Consistency

Admissions committees notice when an application feels rushed. Double-check that your writing across the Common App essay, activities list, and supplements is consistent in tone and in the present tense or past tense where appropriate. Use complete sentences in essays, but short, action-packed phrases in the activities section.

Common Submission Errors

• Misordering activities (listing less impactful ones first).
• Submitting essays with typos or mismatched formatting.
• Forgetting to review the testing section or grades section for accuracy.
• Uploading the wrong draft of your college essay or supplements.

Take one last pass before clicking submit. Even better: have someone else read through it.

FAQs About Common App Sections That Matter

Q: Should I always use all 10 slots in the activities section?

A: No. Quality matters more than quantity. It’s better to list seven activities with depth than 10 with filler.

Q: Can I submit extra letters of recommendation?

A: Only if the college allows it and the recommender adds new insight (e.g., a research mentor).

Q: What should I put in the additional information section?

A: Use it only to explain unique circumstances, responsibilities, or disruptions to your academic record. Avoid repetition.

Build Your Strongest Application with Spark Admissions

The Common Application can feel like a maze, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. At Spark Admissions, we provide expert guidance on every step of preparing for and applying to college. More than that, we help students use this period as a time for growth, developing leadership and communication skills, pursuing internships, and building confidence in their own voices.

Ready for a polished application? Connect with a Spark counselor and put your best story forward.

About The Author