Extracurriculars Freshman Year: Try New Things or Build Depth?

High school students often hear conflicting advice about how to approach extracurricular activities during freshman year. Some are told to try new things, explore interests, and simply enjoy the beginning of high school without pressure. Others hear that top colleges expect early commitment, meaningful activities, and the first signs of leadership long before junior year. Students and families understandably wonder which is true, especially as the college admissions process becomes more selective each year.

The reality is that extracurriculars during freshman year serve two essential purposes. Students need enough exploration to discover their own interests and enough depth to begin building a foundation that can grow over four years. This balance helps students eventually demonstrate leadership, make meaningful contributions to their community, and shape a compelling resume that resonates with admissions officers. Freshman year is not about choosing a lifelong career path but rather about setting the stage for a high school experience that leads to a strong college application.

Why Exploration and Depth Both Matter in Freshman Year

For many students, high schools offer extracurricular activities that extend far beyond those available in middle school. From the debate team to Model UN, robotics club, student government, research programs, volunteer work, and sports teams, there are more opportunities than any student can reasonably join. College admissions officers want to see depth, but they also care about curiosity, initiative, and the ability to try new things. The first year of high school is the best moment to experiment while also maintaining one or two meaningful carryover commitments.

Exploration is especially important because interests at ages fourteen and fifteen are naturally broad and fluid. Students might discover new passions simply by joining activities that expose them to unfamiliar subjects. Someone who has loved writing for years might join the school newspaper and find that journalism provides a fun way to write for an audience. A student with an interest in science might explore the engineering club or the coding team and later pursue more responsibility or leadership roles in these organizations.

Depth, however, matters just as much. Admissions officers and college admissions committees value long-term commitment, meaningful activities, and the ability to grow within an organization. Even freshmen who are still trying new things can continue one or two activities they have enjoyed for years. A student who has played violin since childhood may continue with orchestra, while a student who loves running may join the track team to build continuity and skill. These commitments demonstrate that students can stick with an activity even as they explore other opportunities.

Related Article: Best Extracurriculars for College

A Two-Track Activity Plan for Freshmen

The most effective extracurricular strategy at the beginning of high school is a two-track approach. Students benefit when they explore two or three new options while continuing one or two carryover activities. This structure allows students to try new things in high school without losing opportunities to develop depth and passion. It also prevents students from joining too many clubs, which often leads to burnout and makes it harder to focus academically.

Students who begin high school with a balance between exploration and continuity can adjust naturally as the year progresses. They have space to participate in different organizations, learn from new experiences, and understand their own interests. This structure also helps students build a realistic weekly schedule that includes academics, sports, extracurricular activities, and enough time outside of the classroom to maintain good grades and a healthy routine.

A sample schedule for extracurriculars freshman year might include one afternoon per week for something exploratory, one day for a sports team or long-standing activity, one flexible slot for meetings, and occasional weekend volunteer work. This structure ensures students stay involved in a meaningful way without overcommitting.

How to Evaluate Whether an Activity Is the Right Fit

By mid-winter of freshman year, students should evaluate their existing commitments to determine which of them are worth continuing. The decision should revolve around three key factors: interest level, access to meaningful participation, and long-term impact potential.

Interest plays the biggest role. Students should ask whether the activity still feels engaging, whether they look forward to meetings, and whether the club or team connects to their passions and future goals. Access matters because some extracurricular activities offer stronger opportunities to participate, lead, or create projects than others. A club with too many members might feel less fulfilling for a student who prefers more responsibility, while a smaller organization might provide a better environment for growth.

Impact potential refers to what a student could realistically accomplish over four years. Admissions officers pay attention to depth, initiative, and the ability to contribute in a meaningful way. If a student joins the debate team and finds that they enjoy competition and research, this activity may offer long-term opportunities for leadership roles, captaining a squad, or mentoring younger students in junior and senior years. Similarly, a student who loves animals might begin volunteering at an animal shelter and later raise money, coordinate events, or start a non-profit initiative.

These factors help students determine which activities should move forward into sophomore year. The process does not require expertise or long-term certainty, but it does require honesty and reflection. Students gain a better understanding of their own interests when they pause midyear to consider what they want to continue.

Turning Spring into a Mini-Capstone or Leadership Runway

Spring semester of freshman year is an ideal time to build early momentum. Students can turn one activity into a small project or mini-capstone experience. This could mean writing an article for the school newspaper, organizing a weekend volunteering project for a community organization, or completing a beginner research assignment in a STEM club. Small projects help students participate in a meaningful way and begin to demonstrate leadership within their chosen activities.

These early experiences also prepare students for future opportunities like summer programs, an internship, or specialized academic enrichment. Students who complete a small project freshman year often find that they enter sophomore year with more confidence and clarity. They also gather early achievements that colleges care about when evaluating the trajectory of a student’s high school experience.

Students who know they want to pursue leadership positions later can also use spring to learn from older students, observe how clubs operate, and understand how they might contribute more responsibly in the future. Leadership roles are usually earned after demonstrating consistent involvement, and freshman year provides the foundation for this growth.

Crafting a Compelling Multiyear Narrative

Extracurricular activities from freshman to senior year ultimately shape a student’s college application narrative. Colleges want to see how students participate over time, what they care about, and how they make a meaningful contribution to their campus or community. The most compelling applications show a progression where early exploration leads to a clear area of focus, and early participation leads to substantial involvement or leadership.

Students who plan their freshman-year extracurriculars with intention are better able to develop career goals, deepen a specific subject interest, or eventually build a resume in an area that matters to them. Even students who begin the year with few activities can create an excellent trajectory with the right mix of exploration and depth.

Admissions committees evaluate extracurricular activities in the context of grades, test scores, and the rest of the application. Students who start thoughtfully in ninth grade give themselves more time to grow, explore, adjust, and eventually excel. Freshman year should not feel stressful, but it should feel purposeful.

How Many Activities Should a Freshman Join?

Most students should join only a few activities to avoid overcommitment. It is better to participate meaningfully in two or three extracurriculars than to join seven and struggle to contribute. Colleges care far more about depth than quantity.

Is It Okay to Quit an Activity Freshman Year?

Yes. Freshman year is the ideal time to try new things. If a student discovers that a club or sport does not align with their interests, it is reasonable to adjust. It is better to quit early than to stretch yourself thin.

Can Sports and Music Still Matter If They Are Not Related to a Student’s Career Goals?

Absolutely. Colleges want to admit students who show discipline, teamwork, artistry, and long-term commitment. Sports, orchestra, and other structured activities play an important role even for students pursuing unrelated academic interests.

Create a Freshman Activity Plan with Spark Admissions

Spark Admissions specializes in helping students build a thoughtful, intentional extracurricular strategy starting as early as eighth grade and freshman year. We understand what top colleges want to see, how extracurriculars matter, and how students can balance exploration with meaningful commitment. Our team helps students evaluate their interests, find activities that align with their strengths, and design a plan they can build on throughout high school.

We provide expert guidance on every step of preparing for and applying to college, but we do not stop there. In addition to offering application guidance, we help students navigate the academic demands of high school, gain practical experience, and heighten their leadership and communication skills.

Spark Admissions works with students to ensure they feel confident, capable, and prepared for every part of the admissions process, from freshman year to senior year. Reach out to get started.

About The Author

Dr. Rachel Rubin

Dr. Rachel Rubin is the co-founder of Spark Admissions and holds a doctorate from Harvard University, where she was a Presidential Scholar. A former university faculty member and high school teacher, she understands the needs of adolescents and excels in guiding them through the admissions process, from identifying best-fit colleges to refining application essays. A U.S. Presidential Scholar and member of the Independent Educational Consultants Association, Dr. Rubin has helped thousands of students gain acceptance to their top-choice schools.

See author's posts